Every so often, an audition on Got Talent surprises everyone, creating a moment so impactful that viewers can’t help but watch it over and over. This was one of those awe-inspiring performances.

Five young men stepped onto the Britain’s Got Talent stage and introduced themselves as Collabro. When they mentioned they’d only been performing together for a month, Simon Cowell’s reaction was less than enthusiastic, rolling his eyes as if bracing for another mediocre boy band audition. Judge Alesha Dixon, curious yet doubtful, asked, “Why do you think you could win Britain’s Got Talent with just a month together?” With calm confidence, the group’s leader replied, “Natural chemistry.” Amanda Holden lowered her head, trying to hide her amusement.

“Alright, let’s see what you’ve got,” Alesha said. Collabro didn’t waste a second. They opened with a haunting solo to “Stars” from Les Misérables, and the room fell silent. The performance grew even more powerful as a second member’s voice filled the theater, leading to a chorus that left the audience in awe. The judges’ skeptical smiles quickly turned to expressions of shock and admiration. Before the song was over, the audience erupted in applause, giving them a standing ovation.

It’s rare to see judges change their minds so quickly, but that night, they did. Amanda Holden, who initially chuckled at their confidence, called their performance “absolutely brilliant.” With their natural chemistry and undeniable talent, Collabro went on to win Britain’s Got Talent 2014 in what felt like a real-life fairytale.

Their rendition of “Stars” became an internet sensation, amassing over 51 million views on YouTube. Collabro’s story reminds us that talent and determination can create magic, and that the most surprising performances are often the most unforgettable.